K-pop group X:IN has faced significant criticism following live performances, particularly for their vocals during a recent encore. This scrutiny is not uncommon in the K-pop industry, where idols are frequently evaluated on their live singing abilities, an aspect that often garners intense public scrutiny regardless of the performers’ experience levels.
The group’s latest comeback, highlighted by the track "Attention Seeker," has sparked backlash from netizens who voiced concerns regarding the quality of the members’ vocals. In discussions on platforms such as Reddit, several users described the performance as "grating," pointing to issues with the vocal direction that detracted from the song’s overall enjoyment.
Visuals of the group performing the new track showcase the members engaging the audience, yet the vocal feedback overshadowed the performance itself. Critics have suggested that the unique vocal characteristics of the members have not resonated well in this release, with one observer noting that these traits "ruin" the listening experience for many fans.
Despite the overwhelmingly negative feedback on their vocals, some listeners did show a degree of appreciation for the group’s effort, acknowledging that not all elements of the release were poorly received. However, there is a general consensus among part of the fanbase that the current vocal direction poses challenges in making the songs more accessible.
As X:IN navigates the challenges of public perception following this release, the discourse around their performances and vocal abilities will likely continue, influencing future releases and the direction of their artistry.
